Immigrant Paperwork Trap Fuels Arrests
A recent investigation by the Cato Institute reveals that the Trump administration has fundamentally altered the role of U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), shifting it from processing applications for citizenship, green cards, work permits, and asylum to assisting arrests of legal immigrants by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE).
By cutting green card approvals by about 50%, the Trump administration has effectively set up legal immigrants for arrest and deportation.
The strategy relies on creating a deliberate administrative bottleneck. By stalling or suspending the processing of legal permanent residence applications, USCIS allows an applicant’s temporary status (such as a visa or parole) to expire. Once that status lapses, the individual becomes vulnerable to ICE, even if they are legally eligible for a green card. USCIS Director Joseph Edlow has openly touted this synergy, noting that the agency now identifies individuals for arrest directly from its field offices.
The policy shifts target three immigrant groups:
- Families of U.S. Citizens: Despite being a historically protected category, family-sponsored approvals dropped 54% between July 2025 and January 2026. ICE detained numerous spouses of U.S. citizens, including a Ukrainian refugee and the wife of an active-duty Navy sailor, after their temporary protections expired during USCIS delays.
- Cuban Nationals: By suspending applications under the Cuban Adjustment Act, the administration facilitated a 463% increase in arrests of Cubans who would otherwise be eligible for permanent residency.
- Refugees: In perhaps the most controversial move, USCIS and ICE launched “Operation PARRIS.” The agencies reinterpreted old statutes to arrest refugees who had been in the country over a year but had not yet received green cards due to agency backlogs. This has led to high-profile raids where nursing mothers and long-term residents were shackled and sent to Texas detention centers.
The administration’s mass deportation strategy does not just target undocumented individuals; it actively manufactures “illegality” by withholding the very status immigrants are legally entitled to. By weaponizing administrative delays, the government has transformed the path to citizenship into a pipeline for detention.
FAITH IN ACTION: Denounce wrongful arrests.
Read the full report here.
Photo: Courtesy of Gulbenk, available in the public domain via Wikimedia Commons.
